Starring;
Werner Herzog
Michael Perry
Jason Burkett
Director;
Werner Herzog
In three words; Harrowing - Tragic - Haunting
Plot;
Werner Herzog
is back in documentary territory with a look at capital punishment in America. After
the murder of three people in Texas Michael Perry and Jason Burkett are
convicted of the killings. Herzog profiles the affect the deaths had on the
victim’s family and also on Perry and Burkett. This is an examination on humanity
and why people kill. Whether that is in cold blood or court ordered.
Review;
Michael Perry
and Jason Burkett were involved in a triple murder which occurred in Conroe,
Texas in October 2001. What started out as an attempt to steal a car turned
into three people being murdered and Perry and Burkett ending up in prison,
receiving the death penalty and life without parole respectively.
Herzog
investigates the fallout caused by these murders, not just for the victims’
families but also for the perpetrators. Whilst the director is quick to point out
that he disagrees with capital punishment he does not deliver the film in a
judgemental way towards the current law which is in place in Texas. Instead he
takes us through a journey of mortality and makes the audience think about
their own opinions on taking life away from someone even when they have committed
a terrible crime.
The
interviews with Perry and Burkett are incredibly interesting and insightful as
they speak candidly about the night which changed their lives whilst continually
blaming each other for the crimes committed. What is particularly haunting is
that Perry is speaking with only eight days to go before he is due on the
gurney where is life will end. Their interviews are magnified by the reinforced
glass which they speak to Herzog through.
However, the
most important interviews in this documentary are with the victim’s families,
the prison chaplain and also a former prison officer who can no longer face
another execution. Also Burkett’s father, who is also in prison recalls his testimony
in court which he believes helped his son avoid the death penalty. Having never
been there for his children he blames himself for where his son now finds himself.
However, Herzog shrewdly interviews others associated with Perry and Burkett
and one of the victim’s brothers who all had a difficult time growing up yet
they have managed not to kill anyone!
My only criticism
is that Herzog delivers marathon questions to his interviewees whereby they end
up only answering one or two of the questions he has asked. He also kept
putting words into the mouths of his subjects which tainted their responses.
Despite this the documentary is well filmed and is certainly the best I have
seen since Bowling for Columbine.
Verdict;
3 out of 5.

No comments:
Post a Comment